Laboratory tests for glycosylated haemoglobin (HbA1c) can underestimate past glycaemia in people with haemoglobin variants, such as those with sickle cell trait. This is because there is an increased red cell turnover in those with haemoglobin variants. This means that HbA1c tests, which estimate the glucose level over the preceding few weeks will be unreliable.

MNSI investigations identified that HbA1c tests were taken in mothers with sickle cell trait, when they were being tested for gestational diabetes. These tests were not processed by the laboratories, as the results of these tests are unreliable. There was no further evaluation of the diabetes risk in these mothers. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) does not recommend HbA1c as a test for gestational diabetes in pregnancy, instead recommending a 2-hour oral glucose tolerance test. The HbA1c test may be used to assess women with pre-existing diabetes, to assess the level of risk for the pregnancy (NICE, 2015).

  • How does your trust ensure that staff are aware that HbA1c testing is not reliable in mothers with haemoglobin variants including sickle cell trait?
  • How does local guidance support staff to ensure there is further evaluation of diabetes in mothers with haemoglobin variants when considering HbA1c testing, as the result may underestimate past glycaemia?
  • Is there a process in your trust for following up mothers who have samples rejected by the laboratory due to haemoglobin variants, so that an alternative method of testing for measurement of long-term sugar control is offered?

Related news

Maternal Care Bundle safety spotlights

We welcome the publication of the Maternal Care Bundle by NHS England and are delighted to have been a key contributor in its development. A series of safety spotlights follow.
Read the full article

Safety spotlight: Late diagnosis of breech presentation

MNSI has completed a number of investigations where there has been a late diagnosis, in established labour, of a baby being in breech presentation during an induction of labour.
Read the full article

MNSI establishes Editorial Board

MNSI has established a new Editorial Board to support the quality and consistency of its publications, strengthening its commitment to producing high-quality, accessible content that reflects its mis…
Read the full article

Reflecting on a year of progress for the Maternity and Newborn Safety Investigation programme

As 2025 draws to a close, we want to share some reflections on what a significant year it has been for the Maternity and Newborn Safety Investigations (MNSI) programme.
Read the full article

Putting families at the heart of safer maternity and newborn care

The Maternity and Newborn Safety Investigations (MNSI) programme has published its 2025–27 strategy, building on its approach to improving maternity and newborn safety.
Read the full article
© 2026 MNSI. All rights reserved.